CDAI
Integrated Technical Solutions
Two Securities Centre
Suite 345
3500 Piedmont Road
Atlanta, Georgia 30305
Tel (404) 633-8861
Fax (404) 636-5089
Email info@cdai.com

 

 

 

Why do I need a specialty consultant?

Properly designing and integrating technologies into buildings can potentially be a very complex undertaking. A specialty consultant can be your advocate in dealing with the myriad of technical issues that arise on a project. Since a true independent specialty consultant is not aligned with manufacturers or dealers, he can make decisions based solely on his client's interests and act to protect those interests every step of the way. A good specialty consultant will intervene if necessary and work to mediate disagreements that often arise between manufacturer's and dealers so that the owner's interests are fully protected. Since the consultant has the ability to specify any product that is available, manufacturer's know that it is in their long term interest to provide products that perform and to back those products up, even if it means bending their standard policies to do so.

My dealer says he provides consulting services? What services do you provide that he doesn’t?

Dealers or vendors typically do not prepare the detailed design and record documentation that specialty consultants require and, by the nature of their involvement, cannot provide a disinterested third party oversight of the installation process. Finally, few vendors are experienced in working with the various Design Professionals (Architects, Engineers, and Interior Designers). Vendors also typically do not address certain important aspects of the facility (such as acoustics, lighting, space planning, etc.) as thoroughly as an independent consultant does and often lack the staff resources to enable them to do so at all.

Why should I hire a specialty consultant and pay a fee when I can get a vendor to put the system in for just the cost of the equipment?

There is no free lunch. Vendors do charge for their engineering as well as their installation effort and this charge is generally over and above the normal mark-up margin on the equipment. Also, a vendor will typically have dealer agreements with only certain manufacturers and will strive to meet sales quotas set by those manufacturers. Finally, vendors do not generally engineer the systems they provide prior to quoting a price. Typically a dealer's "design" is reflected in an equipment list attached to a quote referencing a purchase order.

Why should CDAI design the lighting and acoustics in your presentation space?

Presentation spaces are complicated environments that are, in effect, very similar to theaters. Good acoustical characteristics are vital in that the ability of listeners to understand the program material is affected by the amount of reverberant sound energy and the level of background noise in the space. If visual media are used, and particularly if front projection is needed, the projection screen should not be illuminated by sources other than the projector. Lighting design and control is also key - often it is necessary for the presenter to be seen, the listeners can take notes and still see the projected images - it is not uncommon for these requirements to conflict with each other. Understanding these functional requirements enables CDAI to design the systems (audio/video/control and lighting) to meet the users needs.

Why can’t the Architect and Electrical Engineer on the project handle the design of the technologies in the presentation space?

Few architects or engineers have the specialized training required to properly engineer the technologies used in presentation systems. The continuing development of these technologies, the rapidly changing marketplace and the degree of continuing education required are significant. While the coordination required with other trades requires CDAI to have an understanding of the basic building trades, those trades require their own degrees of specialization and continuing education. In general, the training and experience needed to properly design technical systems is very different from and more specialized than the training and experience that most architects and engineers have

At CDAI, trained specialists in audio, video, controls, lighting and acoustics analyze, design and fully engineer the technical systems and environments in conjunction with the project architects and engineers to achieve fully integrated systems and facility designs.

Why shouldn't the electrical engineer design the sound/audiovisual systems?

The specialization required in properly designing audio, video, and control systems is far different from that required in the normal building trades. This is why in most instances where electrical engineers are given responsibility for technical systems; the work ends up being done by a vendor, or with significant input from a vendor. At CDAI, trained specialists in audio, video, controls, lighting, and acoustics analyze, design and fully engineer the systems and environments working with Architects and Electrical engineers to achieve fully integrated system and facility designs.

When should the specialty consultant be hired?

Ideally the specialty consultant should be hired at the beginning of the project, when square footages are allotted and the bubble diagram or building concepts are being developed. Presentation technology requirements will drive the design for the facility. Sight lines, viewing angles, image size, etc., will all impact the configuration of a presentation space. It is better to establish these requirements early in the process before significant design investments have been made. It becomes a matter of "function over form."

Who should hire the specialty consultant, the Owner or the Architect?

Since the speciality consultants's responsibilities (for systems' check-out, commissioning, training) typically continue after the design team's responsibilities, it is not uncommon for the contract to be direct with the Owner. The Owner ultimately pays for the consultant and should have direct access to the consultant's advice regardless of the contract arrangements.

Why does the Specialty Engineering Consultant need to make site visits during construction?

The infrastructure (conduit, connection boxes, etc.) for a technical system is specific to that system and may impose requirements the traditional electrical trades are inexperienced in dealing with. The electrical consultant may also not be familiar with the infrastructure requirements. CDAI has found it necessary to make at least minimal site visits during construction to review conduit and connection box placements, to review the general construction progress and to address problems in coordination of the specialty items with the base trades. This is particularly important if value engineering or other modification exercised have been performed on the base building since the start of construction.

When should the installation of the specialty systems be contracted?

The installation for the specialty systems should be contracted approximately 6 to 9 months (depending on system complexity) from the substantial completion date of the base building. The specialty contractor generally does not need to be under the general contractor, although he will need to coordinate with some of the base building trades such as the electrical contractors work. The specialty contractor will order, receive and build up equipment racks off site during the final stages of the building construction. When the final finishes are being installed, (carpet, paint, etc.) the racks will be delivered and the remaining equipment installed.

What do you mean by "Construction Administration" and "Commissioning"?

As part of the overall process, as building becomes substantially complete, the systems begin to come together and the installation moves into testing, troubleshooting and finally, systems acceptance and sign-off. This "shakedown" can take from a few days to several months, depending on system complexity and usually overlaps the end users beginning use of the systems. Final refinements to control operations to accommodate minor preference changes are normally made at this point and discrepancies are identified and corrected. At final review and completion of discrepancy corrections, the system are fully "tweaked" or commissioned. Systems' warranties should not go into effect until after the system have been commissioned.

At the time of acceptance, the Owner should be provided with a set of "as-built" documentation. This documentation will enable the Owner to truly have control over his systems - easy troubleshooting, vendors will not need to spend excessive, billable, time spooling up on the systems intent and functionality, and should the Owner wish to change maintenance contracts he's not tied to only one vendor because "he knows the system."

Who teaches us how to use this stuff?

Ideally, the Specialty Consultant that designed the system should provide training. The installing contractor will typically not know all of the history behind the design nor will he know all of the details. For complex systems, training require multiple sessions as the end users first learn the basic operations and then progress to use more of the sophisticated capabilities of the system. In addition, if desired, CDAI can develop an interactive reference program that can be installed on computers and accessed by end users on the facility's network.

What does being a Professional Consulting Engineering firm mean to our clients?

This means that CDAI's clients have, in CDAI, a resource that will work in accordance with professional ethical standards to protect their interests and to provide expert advice that is based on engineering principles. As professional engineers, CDAI does not "wing it" in developing system designs. Design decisions are based on analytical calculations backed up by experience. When developing new and innovative approaches, CDAI proves out analytically developed solutions by using such methods as computer modeling, physical mock-ups and/or other evaluative techniques.

The result is that CDAI designed systems work as intended, are installed to professional standards, are documented for future reference and are able to be fully and easily utilized by CDAI's clients.

Webster's defines the terms as follows:

Professional - characterized by or conforming to the technical or ethical standards of a profession.

Consulting - providing professional or expert advice

Engineering - the application of science and mathematics by which the properties of matter and the sources of energy in nature are made useful to man in structures, machines, products, systems and processes.

© 2003 Cape Dixson Associates Incorporated

About Us | Acoustics | Audiovisual | FAQ | Lighting | Pressroom | Project Solutions | Project Timelines | Theatre | Request Information